A Note from Angela

Growing up in the Midwest in the ‘90s and early 2000s, I remember the excitement of baking cookies from those little tubes of store-bought dough. Back then, I didn’t think twice about ingredients—I just loved cookies. But as I got older, I realized that many of those nostalgic treats were loaded with preservatives, artificial flavors, and ingredients that didn’t feel great to eat.

My own gluten sensitivities, combined with my years in the culinary industry, showed me just how limited the options were for truly delicious, allergen-friendly cookies. That was my sign to create something better—a cookie made with real, high-quality ingredients that everyone could enjoy, regardless of dietary restrictions.

At You're a Cookie!, we believe no one should have to settle for anything less than a crazy good cookie. So we make ours gluten-free, nut-free, and ridiculously delicious—without compromise.

Because everyone deserves a cookie that tastes like home.

FAQ

Find the most frequently asked questions below.

All ingredients sourced to make our cookies are organic and non-gmo. Our current packaging does not reflect that as we are currently awaiting our certifications to process.

Yes we are celiac safe. All our ingredients are certified gluten free and our facility is 100% gluten free.

Yes, we are 100% peanut free and mostly tree nut free. The only 'tree nut' in our facility is Coconut! No other tree nuts exist in our facility.

At the moment we only cater events larger than 150 guests. Please email us if you meet this order minimum.

We got you! Baking can be intimidating, but we are here to help make it more fun.
All our baking instructions are located on the back of each cookie dough bag.

Soon, stay tuned!

We are working in our magical kitchen to create a sugar substitute cookie that will be safe to consume for people with diabetes and/or other dietary preferences - and it will not taste healthy!! Finally!

We get it, it's hard to find a GOOD gluten free cookie, so we took it a step further + made you a CRAZY GOOD Gluten Free Cookie! 

Our Cookies are made traditionally, with ZERO shortcuts and proprietary formulas to ensure that you have the best cookie that gluten free can bring! 

Don't take our word for it, share with friends and family -- let us know what they think ;)

Yes! Our online store is now open for pre-orders. At the moment, we are only offer our pre-baked cookies online.

Dough can be found at stores around the Midwest. Find one close to you!

If you go to our store locator page, you can type in your zip code. 

Please notice that each location may carry different items. Some grocery stores may only carry dough, while some coffee shops may only carry baked cookies.

We no longer have a storefront, but this won't be forever.

As the demand for crazy good cookies went up, we had to expand within our current facility.

Stay tuned for updates on this in the future!

No - we do not make custom cookie orders.

Yes - we are happy to R&D a custom cookie for a foodservice facility. Please email our wholesale team to learn more.

We'd love to provide you with crazy good cookies. After reviewing our Wholesale page, reach out and let us know how we can help!

Send us an email - let's talk ;)

Yes! Stay tuned!

We will announce via our social media channels and newsletter.

Subscribe | Get 10% off your First Order

* indicates required